A Collector's Guide to Ithaca Double Barrel Shotgun Models & Classic Side-by-Sides
PDF / 547 KB Download

As a lifelong hunter and firearms enthusiast, I’ve always been captivated by the elegance and craftsmanship of Ithaca double barrel shotgun models. These shotguns represent a golden age of American gunmaking, and understanding their history, variations, and potential value is a rewarding pursuit. The allure of a well-maintained old double barrel gun extends beyond simply owning a firearm; it’s about connecting with a legacy. This guide will delve into the world of Ithaca, LC Smith, Parker, and other classic American side-by-sides, covering everything from their origins to identifying key features and assessing their worth. We’ll also touch on some of the common issues – the problem with side-by-side shotguns – and where to find resources for parts and information.

The History of Double Barrel Shotguns: When Were Double Barrel Shotguns Invented?

The concept of a double-barreled shotgun dates back to the early 19th century, though rudimentary forms existed even earlier. While pinpointing a single inventor is difficult, the development of reliable breech-loading mechanisms in the mid-1800s truly propelled the popularity of these firearms. Initially favored by market hunters and those needing quick follow-up shots, double barrel shotguns quickly gained a reputation for reliability and versatility. Hunting regulations and the evolution of game management played a role in shaping the demand for specific shotgun configurations.

American manufacturers like Ithaca, Parker, LC Smith, and Winchester quickly rose to prominence, each developing their own distinct styles and quality standards. The late 19th and early 20th centuries witnessed a boom in double gun production, catering to a wide range of sporting needs, from upland bird hunting to waterfowl pursuits.

The Rise of Ithaca Gun Company

Founded in 1883, Ithaca Gun Company initially focused on producing single-barrel shotguns. However, they quickly expanded into double-barrel production, becoming renowned for their quality and innovation. Ithaca’s early double guns were often based on designs from other manufacturers, but they soon developed their own unique actions and features. Their commitment to precision engineering and durable construction cemented their place in American gunmaking history.

Exploring Ithaca Double Barrel Shotgun Models

Ithaca produced a diverse range of double barrel shotguns over its long history. Here’s a look at some of the most notable models:

  • Ithaca Hammerless: One of Ithaca’s earliest and most popular double guns, known for its robust construction and reliable action. These were often chambered for black powder cartridges initially, but many were later converted for smokeless powder.
  • Ithaca NID (New Improved Design): Introduced in 1909, the NID represented a significant upgrade over the earlier Hammerless models, featuring a more refined action and improved trigger mechanism.
  • Ithaca Flues: High-grade double guns produced from 1920-1948, known for their exceptional craftsmanship and beautiful engraving. These are highly sought after by collectors.
  • Ithaca Model 50: A later iteration of the NID, produced from 1948-1974, offering a balance of quality and affordability.
  • Ithaca Side by Side 20 Gauge: A popular choice for upland bird hunting, known for its lightweight and maneuverability.

Identifying specific Ithaca models requires careful examination of markings, serial numbers, and features. Resources like the LC Smith Collectors Association website (which often has cross-reference information for Ithaca) and dedicated gun forums can be invaluable.

LC Smith Shotguns: A Companion to Ithaca

The L.C. Smith Shotgun Company, while eventually absorbed by Ithaca, produced some of the most beautiful and well-regarded double barrel shotguns in American history. Finding a good LC Smith shotguns book is essential for identification and valuation. The company was known for its innovative designs, particularly its spoon-feed action, and its commitment to high-quality materials and craftsmanship.

The Value of an LC Smith Shotguns Book

A comprehensive LC Smith shotguns book, such as those published by the LC Smith Collectors Association, provides detailed information on model variations, serial number ranges, and historical context. These books are crucial for accurately assessing the value of an LC Smith shotgun, as condition, rarity, and originality all play significant roles. The value can range from a few hundred dollars for a well-used, basic model to tens of thousands for a high-grade, engraved example in excellent condition.

Parker Side by Side: The Pinnacle of American Double Guns

Parker shotguns are widely considered the pinnacle of American double gun manufacturing. Known for their exceptional balance, handling, and craftsmanship, Parker side-by-sides are highly prized by collectors and shooters alike. The Parker brand, like Ithaca and LC Smith, has a rich history and a dedicated following. The Parker side by side represents a significant investment, and understanding the nuances of different models is essential before making a purchase.

The Winchester Parker Reproduction Shotgun: A Modern Take on a Classic

In recent years, Winchester has introduced a reproduction of the Parker side-by-side shotgun, offering a modern interpretation of a classic design. The Winchester Parker reproduction shotgun aims to capture the look and feel of the original Parker guns, but with modern manufacturing techniques and materials. While not a true Parker, these reproductions offer a more affordable entry point into the world of classic double guns.

Common Issues with Side-by-Side Shotguns: The Problem with Side-by-Side Shotguns

While beautiful and functional, side-by-side shotguns are not without their potential issues. Understanding the problem with side-by-side shotguns is crucial for both owners and prospective buyers.

  • Loose Hinges and Locks: Over time, the hinge pin and locking mechanisms can loosen, affecting the gun’s structural integrity and safety.
  • Worn Breech Faces: Repeated firing can erode the breech faces, potentially leading to dangerous gas leaks.
  • Damaged Extractors and Ejectors: These mechanisms can wear or break, hindering the smooth operation of the gun.
  • Stock and Forend Issues: Wood can crack, warp, or become loose, affecting the gun’s handling and aesthetics.

Regular inspection and maintenance by a qualified gunsmith are essential for keeping a side-by-side shotgun in safe and reliable working order. REI’s expert advice on gun maintenance provides a good starting point for understanding basic care procedures.

Finding Parts for American Gun Company Double Barrel Shotguns

Sourcing parts for American gun company double barrel shotgun parts can be challenging, particularly for older models. Here are some resources:

  • Gun Parts Corporations: Gun Parts Corporation is a major supplier of firearm parts, including those for classic double guns.
  • LC Smith Collectors Association: The LC Smith Collectors Association often has a parts exchange or can provide leads on where to find specific components.
  • Specialized Gunsmiths: Gunsmiths specializing in classic double guns often have access to a network of parts suppliers.
  • Online Auctions and Forums: Websites like GunBroker.com and dedicated gun forums can be good sources for finding used parts.

Resources for Further Research

Here are some additional resources for learning more about Ithaca and other classic double barrel shotguns:

  • National Park Service (for historical context on hunting and firearms)
  • Leave No Trace Center for Outdoor Ethics (for responsible hunting practices)
  • USDA Forest Service (for information on hunting regulations and access)
  • LC Smith Collectors Association: https://www.lcsmithguns.com/

Collecting and appreciating Ithaca double barrel shotgun models and other classic side-by-sides is a journey that combines historical research, mechanical understanding, and a passion for American craftsmanship. By understanding the history, variations, and potential issues associated with these firearms, you can ensure that you’re making informed decisions and preserving a piece of American gunmaking heritage.