As a seasoned hunter and outdoor writer with over a decade spent exploring the woods, I’ve heard just about every hunting tip imaginable. One of the most common – and controversial – questions I get asked is: should you pee in a deer scrape? The short answer is… probably not. While the idea stems from a desire to mimic a doe in estrus, modern deer hunting has evolved far beyond this practice. This article will dive deep into the world of deer scrapes, the science behind deer scrape scent, the best doe estrus scent options available, and how to create effective mock scrapes to increase your chances of bagging a buck during the rut.
Deer scrapes aren’t simply where deer relieve themselves. They are crucial communication hubs, especially during the pre-rut and rut. Bucks create scrapes by pawing away the leaf litter down to bare earth, then overhanging a low-hanging branch (the licking branch) to rub their forehead on. This process deposits scent from glands on their forehead, eyes, and feet. According to the National Park Service, these scrapes serve multiple purposes:
There are different types of scrapes too. An active scrape is a freshly worked scrape, often revisited frequently. A golden scrape is a scrape that has been consistently maintained for a longer period. Knowing the difference can help you focus your scent strategy.
While the logic of adding your own scent to a scrape might seem sound, it’s generally considered a poor practice for several reasons:
Instead of relying on this outdated tactic, focus on using commercially available doe estrus scents and creating effective mock scrapes.
The market is flooded with deer scents, so choosing the right one can be overwhelming. Here’s a breakdown of some of the best deer scents, categorized by their purpose:
Doe estrus scent is arguably the most effective scent for attracting bucks during the rut. It mimics the scent of a receptive doe, triggering a strong response in bucks. When considering best doe urine to use during rut, here are some top contenders:
When choosing, consider whether you prefer frozen doe estrus or liquid scents. Frozen scents generally last longer but require more careful handling. Understanding what does doe estrus smell like is also helpful – it’s a musky, slightly sweet odor.
While doe estrus is the primary attractant, using buck attractant during rut can further increase your chances of success. Options include:
A licking branch kit is essential for creating realistic mock scrapes. You’ll need a scent specifically designed for licking branches, such as a best deer licking branch scent from Code Blue or Wyndscent. For scent for mock scrape, use a combination of doe estrus and buck urine.
Mock scrapes in September can be a great way to pattern bucks before the rut. Here’s how to build a successful mock scrape:
A black widow mock scrape kit can simplify this process, providing all the necessary components. Remember to use a scent drags for hunting to carry your scent to the scrape location, further enhancing its realism.
How you deliver the scent is just as important as the scent itself. Here are some common methods:
The debate between best synthetic doe estrus and natural scents continues. Natural scents, like those from Code Blue and Wyndscent, are generally considered more effective due to their realistic aroma. However, synthetic scents can be a good option for hunters concerned about disease transmission or scent regulations.
Knowing when to start using estrus scent is crucial. Begin using doe estrus scent during the pre-rut, gradually increasing the intensity as the rut approaches. When to use estrus scent depends on your location and the local deer breeding cycle. Using estrus pre rut can help attract bucks and establish a scrape location. The best time to use tinks 69 is often during peak rut activity.
Some hunters use deer calming scent like Ever Calm to reduce deer anxiety. Ever calm deer scent review suggest it can be helpful, but it’s not a substitute for proper scent control. And to answer the question of why is deer pee blue, it's due to the presence of urea and other compounds in the urine, which can sometimes appear bluish when exposed to air.
Ultimately, successful deer hunting with scent requires knowledge, patience, and a commitment to ethical hunting practices. By understanding deer behavior, choosing the right scents, and creating effective mock scrapes, you can significantly increase your chances of a rewarding hunt. Remember to always check local regulations regarding the use of deer scents, as rules can vary by state and hunting area. Refer to resources like the Leave No Trace Center for Outdoor Ethics and the USDA Forest Service for responsible outdoor practices.